Space does not permit listing the scores of Christian teachers of humanistic
psychology or questionable theology and practices. The major leaders we list
below have dramatically moulded the faith of literally thousands of churches and
millions of Christian people. They may be cited as an illustration of the
problems of this field in general:
Norman Vincent Peale:
He has mixed humanistic psychology and occultic mental
techniques with Christian terminology. For example, in his book on Positive
Imaging, he says you can send thoughts to hover over people's minds,
eventually bursting in on them, compelling them to do things like write out
checks for $5,000. He has also written many forewords to books supporting psychic
practices or teachers. See, for example, his foreword in Helen Keller's My
Religion, where she testifies to her belief in the occultic practices and
philosophy of the 18th century medium Emmanuel Swedenborg.
Robert Schuller:
He has replaced some important biblical doctrines with
modern psychological concepts. This is clearly revealed in his book such as,
Self-Esteem: The New Reformation.
Oral Roberts:
He claims that Jesus personally gave him the "Seed-
aith"
principles. Ultimately, when one reads the Bible, Jesus denies many aspects of
these principles.
Kenneth Copeland:
He claims that he believes in and teaches the doctrine of
the deity of Jesus Christ. Yet in the February 1987 Believers Voice of
Victory magazine, he gives a prophecy of Jesus Christ where Jesus stated
through him: "They crucified me for claiming that I was God. But I didn't claim I was God; I just claimed I walked with Him and that He was in Me.
Hallelujah. That's what you're doing." Copeland stands by this prophecy today.
He must stand by it, of course, otherwise he is guilty of false prophecy. His
response to critics is that he is not denying the deity of Christ, merely that
Christ was saying through him that while on earth He never claimed He was God.
But this is wrong. While He was on earth Christ did claim He was God (John 5:18;
John 10:30; John 14:6; John 20:28). Copeland has also taught that Christ was
"born again" while in hell.
Kenneth Hagin:
He has taught that Christ did not specifically die for our
sins, but instead experienced a sin nature like Adam's. While on the cross, the
important thing that happened was that Christ accepted the sin nature of Satan
in His own spirit. When He was in hell, Jesus became the first one ever "born
again."
Paul Yonggi Cho:
He teaches we can "incubate" or unleash ideas (by thinking,
visualization, and meditation) which will enter what he terms "the fourth
dimension," a level of reality where our ideas can become successful
manipulators of the physical world.
Robert Tilton:
He misinterprets the biblical teaching concerning tithing and
giving money for the ministry in his "Success in Life" programs. For example,
like many other "faith" teachers, he teaches a hundredfold return on giving. If
this principle is really true, then possibly he should give his money to poor
people and thereby increase his wealth a hundredfold, no longer needing people
to send him money.
Charles Capps and John Osteen:
They teach a system of positive confession
that has elements similar to pagan occultism and magic. There are "words of
power" similar to magical spells which, once uttered, powerfully influence
people or change reality. In Dynamics of Faith and Confession (1983)
Charles Capps redefines faith and makes salvation a ritual technique. He teaches
the Virgin Birth was accomplished through Mary's positive confession. Here, he
appears to teach that what Mary conceived by positive confession was not the
eternal second person of the Godhead but the verbal power of God which became
personified on earth as Jesus. "Jesus was the personification of God's Word on
this earth...Jesus in Word form was the creator of all things."
Morton Kelsey:
He is an Episcopal priest and Jungian psychologist, rejects
biblical authority. Kelsey believes Jesus was a psychic and one of the greatest
shamans (or witchdoctors) who ever lived. Christians are to be just like Jesus,
that is, become psychics and shamans, following in His footsteps.
Agnes Sanford:
She was a Jungian, who believed that God could work through
"good" spirits and the spirits of people who have died. She believed God used
some mediums to heal people. Like modern channelers, she also believed that
angels and dead saints could "speak and act in and through us." She accepted
other occult teachings and practices and denied certain important biblical
doctrines.
E. W. Kenyon:
He taught supernatural power is unleashed by the words we
speak. Therefore he said, "You confess that you are perfectly healed while the
disease is making full headway in your body." He would say that if you have to
ask for faith, "all prayer for faith is nothing but unbelief."
Napoleon Hill:
He was a spiritist whose beliefs were derived from or
influenced by the spirit world. For example, see his confession of this in his
book, Grow Rich with Peace of Mind. He is the grandfather of the
Success/Positive Mental Attitude seminars taught widely to leaders in business
and industry.
Jerry Savelle:
He teaches "if you will please God, you will be rich."
The above is only a small sampling of errors that are being taught by
Christian leaders in the Positive Thinking and Faith-Confession movements. In
every case we know of, the root problem is either rejecting the Bible as a final
authority or being ignorant of its teachings.