Jane of Book Reader's Traverse

Jane's PicksBook Reader's Traverse HomeTraversing Guest StationJoel's PicksTracey's Picks

We hope you will find at least a book or two to read from these selections.

A Thread of Grace {Unabridged Audio}. Mary Doria Russell. Books On Tape. 2005. Read by Cassandra Campbell.

Book review by Jane
The story was exceptional, but extremely hard to keep up with while listening on tape. I will need to order the book in book form. This historical novel about WWII Italy covered several different people from different backgrounds, which made it difficult to keep up with the individual story lines while listening. I imagine it would be a little difficult to read, as well, but it would be easier to go back and refresh where the story switches story lines. That being said, it was well worth trying to keep up with the story.

The story was obviously well researched and has a definite real feel to it. Not only does the history ring true, the characters seem genuine and suffer real fates. Very little is candy coated in this war story. The bloodshed appears random as if in a war; whereas people who die often have intricate, complicated lives, same as the survivors. Mostly, it seems Mary Doria Russell does not take sides or play favorites, but instead seems to look at how war affected individuals just trying to have a life. There was an unsettling devil’s advocate passage involving a Nazi that left me uncomfortable and at the same time seemed to express just how cruel the war was to everyone involved. In fact, there are several poignant scenes in this book, representing many different outlooks.

The main situation is that Jewish people from France were trying to escape the Nazis and went into the Alps and over into an Italian valley where the Catholics hid them from the Nazis. That got quite complicated. Ultimately, it is a story of people looking out for people in difficult circumstances. With all the scenes of war, that message is not lost, and is also true to the history.

Jane.


A Thread of Grace Mary Doria Russell. Ballantine Books. 2005.

Book review by Tracey

This was a Goodwill selection, and I’m very glad I took a chance on it. The story set at the end of WWII in Italy. The characters are Jews fleeing from France, German officers, and Italians, Jewish and Christian, among others. There are so many characters that it takes a little while to get them straight, but I ended up loving them all. Ms. Russell makes us see them all as humans, no matter who we identify with the most. That is her point. The reader cannot help but be staggered by the sacrifices that the Jews make to survive and the sacrifices the non-Jews make to help them do so. I am not an organized religion person, and was always told that the Catholic church looked the other way during the extermination of the Jews, but according to this book, there was a lot of Catholic help, at least in Italy. It is a story that makes you want to believe in the goodness of mankind again. It made me wonder what I would do for my neighbors if forced into some of the positions that these characters found themselves in. It’s a good question to ask yourself. This book is very detailed and can be a little confusing to keep together, but definitely worth the read. The wrapped up ending is just a bonus.

Tracey.

 



Visit Book Reader's Traverse Home Page for more selections.

E-mail This Page

Free JavaScripts provided
by The JavaScript Source

Would you like to see more reviews like this one? Jane of Book Reader's Traverse prefers to scan the library database for books to read, grabbing titles from many sources. She reviews many non-fiction titles, as well as some fiction of the day. Visit her picks page for her bio and other reviews--Jane's Picks.

  Sign up for "Book Reader's Traverse Unabashed": our free newsletter where we provide you with our latest selections and commentary on the reading world. We will not share your e-mail address.

Read Behind the Scenes at Book Reader's Traverse--blog 

A Thread of Grace
How would you rate this book?

Won't read.
Burn!
Okay, But couldn't wait to finish
Pretty good.
Good book, will stick with me awhile.
Read again.
 
Fiction
Child Literature
Classics
Comedy Fiction
Fantasy
Historical Fiction
Other Fiction
Regional Fiction
Romantic Fiction
Sci-Fi
Non-Fiction
Art Non-Fiction
Biography
Comedy Non-Fiction
Computer/Internet
Economics
Environment
Gardening
Health
History
Other Non-Fiction
Pets
Regional Non-Fiction
Science
Spiritual

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

©2004-2008 by Book Reader's Traverse. All rights reserved.