Some notes about my list...
If I'm looking for a pony that comes in a so-soft version, I'm after either a NSS version, or a manky version of the SS. I don't really like so-softs, so I'm looking to deflock any that come into my hands!
If ponies come in different poses, I try to specify the one I'm looking for. (Hence why most ponies are marked unicorn or pegasus, because some have the same name...) If not, you can always offer me what you have and I'll let you know if it's what I need!
I'm not a stickler for absolutely mint ponies. I'm rather good at removing flaws when ponies are collection-bound, so if you have ANYTHING on my list... feel free to offer it. You never know if I might accept it or not.

G3 ponies - 2003+
Winter Snow
Pick-a-lilly & Sunny Salsa set
Avalonia set
Winter Snow
Goodie Goodie and Darling Dahlia (out of package is fine)
DaisyJo McDonald's toy

Vintage ponies; by year, according to Dream Valley.
Year 2 (1983-1984)
Twilight (unicorn)
Skydancer (pegasus)
Peachy

Year 3 (1984-1985)
Cherries Jubilee
Sky Flier (unicorn)
Sparkler (unicorn)
Trickles
Confetti (non-Wedding Bells)
Pinwheel (unicorn)
Baby Blossom

Year 4 (1985-1986)
Ribbon (unicorn)
Cupcake
Twist (unicorn)
Bouncy
Fifi
Gingerbread (TE)
Sky Rocket (TE)

Year 5 (1986-1987)
Crumpet
Angel
Locket (TE)
Mimic (TE)
Tic-Tac-Toe (TE)
Bright Eyes (TE)
Love Melody (TAF)
Princess Serena
Princess Starburst
4-Speed
Salty
Quarterback
Slugger
Sniffles & Snookums (unicorn newborn twins)

Year 6 (1987-1988)
Yum Yum (TAF)
Munchy (TAF)
Barnacle
Chief
Sandcastle & Shovels (unicorn newborn twins)
Sticky & Sniffles (newborn twins)
Glow (summerwing)
Lady Flutter (summerwing)

Year 7 (1988-1989)
Sunnybunch (MGR)
Diamond Dreams (MGR)
Flower Bouquet (MGR)
Sweet Celebrations Family
Baby Paws
Baby Countdown
Baby Leaper
Baby Waddles
Wiggles (newborn unicorn)
Cool Breeze (windy wing)
Moon Jumper (windy wing)
Flurry (windy wing)
Starry Wings (windy wing)

Year 8 (1989-1990)
Pina Colada

Year 10 (1991-1992)
Starswirl
Springy
Baby Sea Princess (mermaid)
Baby Sea Shimmer (mermaid)
Baby Pearly (mermaid)